| Trophy | Requirement |
| I AM the Batman! (Platinum) | Reclaim your city. |
| A Leap of Faith (Bronze) | Complete 8 different jumps over 100 meters. |
| Absolution (Bronze) | Achieve 69 Stars in AR Challenges. |
| Blunt Trauma (Bronze) | Perform every type of predator takedown. |
| Brutality 101 (Bronze) | Perform 15 different combat moves in one FreeFlow. |
| Choice of Weapons (Bronze) | Use all five Batmobile weapons successfully in one tank battle. |
| City of Fear (Bronze) | Defend the assault on your ally's fortress. |
| Cold World (Bronze) | Destroy the first weapons cache in Gotham City. |
| Creature of the Night (Bronze) | Freedom of the city. |
| Cycle of Violence (Bronze) | Use 100 Quick Gadgets while in free flow combat. |
| Death and Glory (Bronze) | Take out 20 thugs with fear takedowns. |
| Death by Design (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the seventh Riddler trial. |
| Death of Innocents (Bronze) | Rescue station 17 fire crew. |
| Dirty Tricks (Bronze) | Achieve 3 minutes of drifting time in the Batmobile. |
| Fear of Faith (Bronze) | Rescue the ACE Chemical workers. |
| Fortunate Son (Bronze) | Achieve 46 Stars in AR Challenges. |
| Gates of Gotham (Bronze) | Destroy all of the militia watchtowers. |
| Gotham After Midnight (Bronze) | Glide for 400 meters while less than 20 meters from the ground. |
| Gotham Underground (Bronze) | Defuse all of the militia explosive ordinance in Gotham City. |
| Jekyll & Hyde (Bronze) | Stop the bank heist on Miagani Island and lock up the master mind in GCPD. |
| Journey into Knight (Bronze) | Even The Odds. |
| Judgment Day (Bronze) | Win the rumble down under. |
| Lethal Pursuits (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the ninth Riddler trial. |
| Living Hell (Bronze) | Interrogate the Militia APC Driver. |
| Nine Lives (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the last Riddler trial. |
| No Man's Land (Bronze) | Restore power to the bridges of Gotham City. |
| Pieces of the Puzzle (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the second Riddler trial. |
| Point of Impact (Bronze) | Perform 5 perfect shots in a row with the Vulcan Gun without taking damage. |
| Riddler on the Rampage (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the fourth Riddler trial. |
| Run Through the Jungle (Bronze) | Fly under 3 main bridges between the islands in one continuous glide. |
| Savage Metal (Bronze) | Smash 10 militia transport vehicles off the road without using the immobilizer. |
| Seduction of the Gun (Bronze) | Achieve 50 critical shots on light tanks. |
| Sins of Youth (Bronze) | Achieve 23 Stars in AR Challenges. |
| Streets of Gotham (Bronze) | Destroy all of the militia checkpoints. |
| The Burning Question (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the fifth Riddler trial. |
| The Cat and the Bat (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the third Riddler trial. |
| The Frequency of Fear (Bronze) | Scan Gotham City to pinpoint Scarecrow's location. |
| The Monster Machine (Bronze) | Track down and apprehend the serial killer. |
| The Primal Riddle (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the sixth Riddler trial. |
| The Real Deal (Bronze) | Takedown 20 moving cars without using the Batmobile. |
| The Road Home (Bronze) | Destroy all of the militia APC's. |
| The Road to Hell (Bronze) | Successfully complete the first Riddler trial. |
| Touch of Death (Bronze) | Apprehend the weapons dealer and lock him up in GCPD. |
| Trail of Fear (Bronze) | Lock up your first Supervillain in GCPD. |
| With a Vengeance! (Bronze) | Take on the heavy artillery reinforcements. |
| Ambush (Bronze) | Defeat 4 enemies within the duration of a single scare effect. |
| Weird War Tales (Bronze) | Defeat 15 enemies using any type of hacking. |
| A Blade of Memory (Bronze) | Destroy all Teeth, Balloons and Jack-In-The-Boxes. |
| Trophy | Requirement |
| A Battle Within (Bronze) | Fight for your sanity. |
| A Heart Broken in Two (Bronze) | Secure the secret base. |
| Angel in the Dark (Bronze) | Complete the trials and prove you are a worthy successor. |
| As the Crow Flies (Bronze) | Escape from ACE Chemicals. |
| Be Not Afraid (Bronze) | Win the war for Gotham. |
| Brotherhood of the Fist (Bronze) | Return of the Dynamic Duo. |
| Dark Allegiances (Bronze) | Apprehend Scarecrow's senior commander. |
| Dark Wings Fly Away in Fear (Bronze) | What is the Cloudburst? |
| Days of Fire (Bronze) | Extinguish the fires in Gotham City. |
| Double Jeopardy (Bronze) | Face off with an old friend. |
| Fear of Success (Bronze) | Survive Scarecrow's ambush. |
| Knightfall (Gold) | Initiate Knightfall Protocol. |
| Master of Fear (Bronze) | Wayne vs Crane. |
| Riddle Me That (Bronze) | Lock up the Riddler in GCPD. |
| Scar of the Bat (Bronze) | Cure the doctor. |
| Strange Deadfellows (Bronze) | Deploy the Cloudburst countermeasures. |
| The Cult (Bronze) | Save the sacrificial victim and lock up the executioner in GCPD. |
| The Long Halloween (Silver) | Wayne vs Crane in New Story +. |
| The Riddle Factory (Bronze) | Obtain a key by completing the eighth Riddler trial. |
| Who Rules The Night (Bronze) | Batman vs the Arkham Knight. |
| A Fire in the Heavens (Bronze) | Free the hostages at the Ferris Wheel. |
| A House Made of Spun Glass (Bronze) | Free the hostages at the Merry-go-round. |
| The Laughing Fish! (Bronze) | Free the hostages at the Ghost Ship. |
| A Courtship of Razors (Silver) | Rescue your father. |
| All Snug in Their Beds (Silver) | Uncover the secret history of the park. |
| Cuckoo for Incarceration (Silver) | Rescue your friend. |
| Under The Red Hood (Silver) | Shut down this operation. |
| Dark Victory (Silver) | Escape the Nightmare. |